Abstract

A total of 38 different samples of Kohl comprising of 23 indigenous mined products and 15 imported products as control and were analyzed for general elemental composition but with particular interest in those reported to be of relevance (As, Cd, Hg, Ni, Co and Sb) in cosmetics. Energy dispersive X-ray Fluorescence Analysis EDXRA was used for the assay. Only Pb, As, Ni and Cr were detected among the elements of interest. Mean Pb concentrations of 277300 ppm; Ni at 2256 ppm concentration; and As at 810 ppm which are considerably higher than their safety limits (20 ppm p<0.01) were obtained in both the indigenous and imported products. The same risk was statistically observed to be involved following the use of both local and imported kohl products. Again Pb concentrations in excess of what was claimed on the labels of the imported kohl products were observed (p<0.01), hence the need for scrutiny of imported products by the relevant agency. The high concentration of Cr (7460 ppm, p<0.05) in the imported samples signifies its presence as colorant and the need for chromium control for the brands concerned. Also the observed presence of Th in the indigenous (local) samples suggests that Nigerian products may be of radiological effect to health. Measurements were made of gross alpha and beta count of indigenous mined and imported kohl samples The results reveals that all the forms of kohl products assayed, emit both particles but with β’s count substantially higher than the α’s (p<0.5) at a mean β count 4695×10-3 cpm and α count as 283×10-3 cpm. One of the samples from Zamfara State of Nigeria (known for Pb poisoning due to mining activities) shows an exceptionally high count in both α = 8998100 cpm and β = 9315700 cpm which reveals that products from Zamfara State, need a special attention. Application of this product is therefore very much likely to produce radiation damage to the cornea due to low penetration of α and to the internal tissue of the eye due to the relatively high penetration of β s. However, the non-existence of defined safety limits for these particles in Kohl as cosmetic, suggests the need for further research.

Keywords:

EDXRF, eye, kohl, proportional counter, radiation disease, toxic elements,

References

1. Al-Ashban, R.M., M. Aslam and A.H. Shah, 2004. Kohl (surma): A toxic traditional eye cosmetic study in Saudi Arabic. Pub. Health, 118(4): 292-298.
   CrossRef    PMid:15121438    
2. Al-Hazzaa, S.A. and P.M. Krahn, 1995. Kohl: A hazardous eyeliner. Int. Ophthalmol., 19(2): 83-88.
   CrossRef    PMid:8586501    
3. Al-Kaff, A., A. Al-Rajhi, K. Tabbara and A. El-Tazigi, 1993. Kohl-the traditional eye liner: Use and analysis. Ann. Saudi Med., 13: 26-30.
   CrossRef    PMid:17587986    
4. Al-Kawajah, A.M., 1992. Al kohl used in Saudi Arabia: Extentent and possible lead toxicity. Trop. Geograph. Med., 44(4): 373-377.
   
5. Al-Saleh, I.A., C. Fellows, T. Delves and A. Taylor, 1993. Identification of sources of lead exposure to among children in Arrar, Saudi Arabia. Ann. Clin. Biochem., 30: 142-145.
   CrossRef    PMid:8466144    
6. Betts, P.R., R. Astley and D.N. Raine, 1973. Lead intoxication in children in Birmingham. Br. Med. J., 1(5850): 402-406.
   CrossRef    PMid:4691065 PMCid:PMC1588291    
7. Berne Convention, 1964. Life of the cell. 2nd Edn., Simson Shand Ltd London pp: 60-67.
   
8. Cember H., 1992. Introduction to Health Physics. 2nd Edn., McGraw-Hill Inc. Toronto pp: 220-231.
   
9. FDA US Food and drug Administration, 2006. Food drug and Cosmetic Act. Section 201 (1).
   Direct Link
10. Hardy, A.D., H.H. Sutherland and R. Vaishnav, 2002. A study of the composition of some eye cosmetic (Kohls) used in the United Arab Emirates. J. Ethnopharmacol., 80(2-3): 137-145.
    CrossRef    
11. Hardy, A.D., R.I. Walton, K.A. Myers and R. Vaishnav, 2006. Availability and chemical composition of traditional eye cosmetics ("Kohls") used in the United Arab Emirate of Dubai, Sharjah, Ajman, Umm Al-Quwain, Ras Al-Khaimah and Fukairah. J. Cosmet. Sci., 57(2): 107-125.
    PMid:16688375    
12. Hardy, A.D., R. Vaishnav, S.S. Al-Kharusi, H.H. Sutherland and M.A. Worthing, 1998. Composition of eye cosmetics (Kohl) used in Oman. J. Ethnopharmocol., 60(3): 223-234.
    CrossRef    
13. Health Canada, 2006. Consumer Information-health Concerns about Lead in Traditional Kohl.
    Direct Link
14. Health Canada, 2009. Consumer Product Safety, Draft Guidance on Heavy Metal Impurities in Cosmetics. File: Cafe001/documents/ draftguidance on heavy metals impurities in cosmetics.htm.
    
15. Kapoor, V.P., 2007. Kohl and poisoning. Int. Soc. Environ. Botanist, 13(3).
    
16. Lilisa Saino E., R. Jolanki, E. Hakala and L. Kanary, 2001. Metal and arsenic in eye shadows. Contact Dermatitis, 42(3): 5-10.
    
17. Madany, I.M. and A.M. Salim, 1992. Lead levels in some eye cosmetics used in Bahrain. J. Environ. Sci. Health, 27(6): 1541-1547.
    CrossRef    
18. NHMH (New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene), 2007.
    Direct Link
19. Parry, C. and J. Eaton, 1991. Kohl: Lead hazardous eyeliner from the third world. Environ. Health Persp., 94: 121-133.
    CrossRef    PMid:1954922 PMCid:PMC1567936    
20. Shaltout, A., S.A. Yaish and N. Fernando, 1981. Lead Poisoning Encephalopathy in infants in Kuwait. Ann. Trop. Pediatr., 1: 209-215.
    CrossRef    PMid:6185071    
21. Snodgrass, G.J., D.A. Ziderman, V. Gulati and J. Richards, 1973. Letter: Cosmetic plumbism. Br. Med. J., 4(886): 230.
    CrossRef    PMid:4758399 PMCid:PMC1587319    
22. Tabbara, K.F. and E.M. Burd, 1987. Microbial content of kohl. Ann. Saudi Med., 7(3): 177-179.
    CrossRef    
23. Warley, M.A., P. Blackledge and P. O'Gorman, 1968. Lead poisoning from eye cosmetic. Brit. Med. J., 1(584): 117.
    CrossRef    PMid:5634698 PMCid:PMC1984717    

Competing interests

The authors have no competing interests.

Open Access Policy

This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.

Copyright

The authors have no competing interests.